Plant based meat

Highlights

  • Global plant-based meat patent filings fell again in 2024, extending the decline from the sector’s 2021 peak.
  • Europe is still the global leader in plant-based meat innovation, but European applicants filed just half as many patents they did three years prior.
  • Innovators have filed over four times more flavour and texture filings for plant-based meats than 10 years ago, but half as many as in 2021.
  • Soy and pea remain the most popular protein sources in the 2024 patent filings.

Market context

Last year, we reported that plant-based meat patent filings had declined for a second year running. The latest filing data shows that this wasn’t a short pause.

As Figure 1 shows, global priority filings fell from 239 in 2023 to 187 in 2024.

That marks a third consecutive annual decline and leaves filing numbers about 37% below their 2021 peak of 299.

Even so, activity remains well above the level seen before the rapid growth of the early 2020s. In 2019, for example, 115 filings were recorded.

Figure 1: 10-year trend (2015-2024) - global priority filings by year

This graph gives us the clearest answer to one of the questions raised in our report last year – will the filing trend continue, stabilise or reverse? It has continued, and the fall in 2024 was fairly steep.

There is a little more to the story, though. Figure 2 (below) compares annual priority filings with the number of unique assignees (the organisations named as applicants on the new filings).

Unique assignees fell from 150 in 2023 to 134 in 2024. While that represents a ~10% drop, this is smaller than the fall in filing volume.

Put simply, the patent data suggests that fewer organisations left the field than the headline filing figure might imply. Those that remained tended to file fewer new patent applications.

Figure 2: 20-year trend (2005-2024) Unique assignees and priority filings

Geographic landscape

Figure 3 shows that European filings fell from 85 in 2023 to 50 in 2024.

United States filings also declined, from 65 to 49. Europe therefore retained its lead, but only by a single filing.

Figure 3: Ten-year trend (2015-2024) - global priority filings by jurisdiction

Different trends were seen in filings in other countries. Filings in the Republic of Korea rose from 32 to 35, while filings in India increased from three to 11. India’s rise came from a low starting point, so we should be careful about reading too much into this year’s data.

Still, these changes stand out against the downward trends in established filing jurisdictions.

Overall there is a more balanced picture than we saw previously. Europe and the United States remain the two leading jurisdictions in this dataset, but Europe’s previous significant lead in filing numbers didn’t carry through into 2024.

Competitive landscape

The applicant data tells a similar story, although not every major filer followed the same path.

As Figure 6 shows, several established applicants filed fewer applications in 2024 than in 2023. Nestle SA fell from three filings to two, while Roquette Freres fell from seven to two.

Unilever IP Holdings BV dropped from 12 filings to one. Royal DSM NV also recorded one filing, down from four.

Figure 4: ten-year trend (2014-2023) - leading applicants by global priority filings

One company that continued to buck the wider trend was Cargill Inc.

Its filings rose from 14 in 2023 to 16 in 2024, making it the most active applicant in the plant-based meat dataset.

Innovation landscape

Taste and texture have long been difficult issues for plant-based meat producers. The latest patent data suggests they remain firmly on the research agenda.

Figure 5 records 56 flavour-related filings and 45 texture-related filings in 2024. Both categories declined from 2023, when the figures were 96 and 67 respectively.

Flavour-related activity therefore remained higher than texture-related activity, although both moved down with the wider market.

Figure 5: 19-year trend (2006-2024) - global priority filings by flavour and texture

These searches can overlap, so the two figures shouldn’t simply be added together and treated as a share of all plant-based meat filings.

A single patent family may address both flavour and texture.

Even with that qualification, patent filing data suggests that a sizeable body of work in this sector continues to focus on how these products taste and feel.

Established proteins remain out in front

There’s more movement when we look at the protein sources being used, but soy and pea are still well ahead.

As shown in Figure 6, we can see 40 soy protein-related and 40 pea protein-related patent filings in 2024. Soy declined from 54 in 2023, while the numbers for pea protein were broadly stable, moving from 42 to 40.

Both remained ahead of chickpea protein, which rose from 11 to 19 filings. Mung bean-related filings increased from 10 to 12, while the number of fava bean-related filings remained at 11.

Figure 6: 20-year trend (2005-2024) - global priority filings by applicant group

So there is continued interest in a wider range of plant proteins, but it is too early to say that these alternatives are displacing soy and pea protein in importance.

Chickpea protein had a stronger year, but fava bean and mung bean remained at much lower levels, and all three sit below peaks recorded elsewhere in the ten-year period.

The graph points to gradual exploration rather than a wholesale shift in favoured ingredients. The prevalence of hybrid products or precision-fermented ingredients weren’t measured separately in this analysis, so trends in these technologies have not been assessed."

Looking ahead

So, where does that leave the sector? The clearest finding from 2024 filing data is that plant-based meat patent activity is still contracting. Filing numbers fell again, Europe lost much of its previous lead, and many established applicants reduced their activity.

At the same time, the data shows us that established companies are continuing to work on familiar technical problems. Flavour and texture still feature prominently. Soy and pea remain the leading protein sources, while applicants continue to explore chickpea, mung bean and fava bean in smaller numbers of filings.

And so the sector may have moved beyond its busiest period for patent filings. What remains is a more measured effort to solve problems that, for consumers, haven’t gone away.

Meet the attorneys

Jack Braithwaite

Trainee Patent Attorney

Learn more

James Myatt

Partner

Learn more